Home / Knowledge / News / Fashion / Dior can bar resale of its goods by discount stores - ECJ
Dior can bar resale of its goods by discount stores - ECJ
04
May '09
In 2000, Dior concluded a trade mark licence agreement with Société industrielle lingerie (SIL) in respect of the manufacture and distribution of luxury corsetry goods bearing the Christian Dior trade mark. That agreement states that in order to maintain the repute and prestige of the Dior trade mark SIL agrees not to sell, in particular, to discount stores outside the selective distribution network, without written agreement from Dior, and that the licensee must make all necessary provision to ensure that that rule is complied with by its distributors or retailers.

However, since it was faced with economic difficulties, SIL sold goods bearing the Dior trade mark to Copad, a company operating a discount store business. Taking the view that that resale was prohibited by the agreement, Dior brought an action against SIL and Copad for trade-mark infringement. However, the resellers pleaded exhaustion of Dior's trade mark rights, because the goods had been put on the market in the EEA (European Economic Area) with Dior's consent.

The French Cour de Cassation, as the court of last instance, referred questions to the Court of Justice concerning the interpretation of the Trade Mark Directive1 particularly since the licensee disregarded a provision in the licence agreement prohibiting, on grounds of the trade mark's prestige, sale to discount stores outside the selective distribution network.

The Court holds, first, that the proprietor of a trade mark can invoke the rights conferred by that trade mark against a licensee who contravenes a provision in a licence agreement prohibiting, on grounds of the trade mark's prestige, sales to discount stores, provided it has been established that that contravention, by reason of the situation prevailing in the case, damages the allure and prestigious image which bestows on those goods an aura of luxury.

The directive entitles the proprietor of a trade mark to invoke the rights that the trade mark confers on him in respect of a licensee where the licensee contravenes certain provisions in the licence agreement listed in Article 8(2) of the directive, including in particular those concerning the quality of the goods. The quality of luxury goods is not only the result of their material characteristics, but also of the allure and prestigious image which bestows on them an aura of luxury.

In this respect, a selective distribution system such as that at issue, which seeks to ensure that the goods are displayed in sales outlets in a manner that enhances their value, especially as regards positioning, advertising, packaging as well as business policy, contributes to the reputation of the goods at issue and therefore to sustaining the aura of luxury surrounding them.

Consequently, it is conceivable that the sale of luxury goods by the licensee to third parties outside the selective distribution network might affect the quality itself of those goods, so that, in such circumstances, a contractual provision prohibiting such sale must be considered to be falling within the scope of the trade mark directive. It is for the national court to examine whether, taking into account the circumstances of the case before it, contravention by the licensee of a provision such as the one at issue in the main proceedings damages the aura of luxury of the luxury goods, thus affecting their quality.


Must ReadView All

Uzbekistan, S Korea to launch textile techno park in Sept

Textiles | On 19th Feb 2018

Uzbekistan, S Korea to launch textile techno park in Sept

Uzbekistan and South Korea plan to launch a modern textile techno...

3 African nations may face AGOA sanctions if Mitumba banned

Apparel/Garments | On 19th Feb 2018

3 African nations may face AGOA sanctions if Mitumba banned

Rwanda, Tanzania and Uganda will face US trade penalties, including...

India’s Uttar Pradesh woos Tiruppur knitwear industrialists

Apparel/Garments | On 19th Feb 2018

India’s Uttar Pradesh woos Tiruppur knitwear industrialists

Two top Uttar Pradesh government officials visited Tamil Nadu’s...

Interviews View All

Karan Toshniwal
Orange O Tec

Contemporary industry is paying more and more attention to the...

Darshan Mehta
Infinium Polychem

We are spending double digit figures on R&D

Akash Khetan
Narayan Tex Fab

I find it hard to find professionals in Surat

Erik Sy

Manila-based CustomThread is a start-up offering premium custom apparel...

Harmeet Singh

New Delhi-based Jogindra Industries Private Limited provides an assortment ...

Hardik Sanghvi

Idealin Fogging Systems has been engaged in designing and manufacturing...

Larry L Kinn
Suominen Corporation

Larry L Kinn, Senior Vice President - Operations Americas of Suominen...

Kerem Durdag
Biovation II LLC

Kerem Durdag, CEO, Biovation II LLC, provides an insight into future...

Marten Alkhagen
Swerea IVF AB

Marten Alkhagen, Senior Scientist - Nonwoven and Technical Textiles of...

Sanjukta Dutta
Sanjukta's Studio

<b>Sanjukta Dutta</b> creates unique garments by clubbing prints of...

Tony Ward
Tony Ward

"You have to truly understand what your client wants, know her needs, what ...

Madhu Jain
Madhu Jain

She grew up in the walled city of Old Delhi, completed her studies, and...

Press Release

Press Release

Letter to Editor

Letter to Editor

RSS Feed

RSS Feed

Submit your press release on


editorial@fibre2fashion.com

Letter To Editor






(Max. 8000 char.)

Search Companies





SEARCH

February 2018

Subscribe today and get the latest update on Textiles, Fashion, Apparel and so on.

news category


Related Categories:

Planning to Take the Leap towards
Sustainability?

Do you see sustainability as a route to business growth?

Yes No

Do you think the sustainability space has the needed tools and resources available for a business to lead change?

Yes No

Active Poll

Do you see sustainability as a route to business growth?

Yes
70.6%
No
12.7%
Skip
16.7%

Total Votes: 102

Do you think adopting a sustainable approach will be a profitable move for your business?

Yes No

Active Poll

Do you think the sustainability space has the needed tools and resources available for a business to lead change?

Yes
63.7%
No
29.4%
Skip
6.9%

Total Votes: 102

Do you want the world to know about your sustainability journey and your business’ environmental footprint?

Yes No

Active Poll

Do you think adopting a sustainable approach will be a profitable move for your business?

Yes
88.2%
No
8.8%
Skip
2.9%

Total Votes: 102

Thanks for your valuable feedback. Claim your free latest sustainability e-book.

Active Poll

Do you want the world to know about your sustainability journey and your business’ environmental footprint?

Yes
83.3%
No
7.8%
Skip
8.8%

Total Votes: 102


E-News Insight
Subscribe Today and Get the
Latest News Update in Your Mail Box.
Advanced Search