Home / Knowledge / News / Textiles / Saxmere appeals against judgement in favour of Wool Board
Saxmere appeals against judgement in favour of Wool Board
25
Jul '09
Saxmere Co Ltd and associated appellants have appealed to the Supreme Court seeking the setting aside of a judgment of the Court of Appeal in favour of the Wool Board Disestablishment Co Ltd, adverse to the appellants, on the ground that the Hon Justice Wilson, a member of the Court of the Appeal Bench in that case, may have been unconsciously biased by reason of friendship and a business connection with one of the Wool Board's counsel in the case, Mr Galbraith QC.

The Supreme Court has unanimously dismissed the appeal holding that, in accordance with the well-established test, a fair-minded lay observer would not reasonably apprehend that the Judge did not bring an impartial mind to the resolution of the question before the Court of Appeal. The appellants have not articulated a logical connection between the Judge's friendship and business association with counsel and the possibility of some deviation by the Judge from the course of deciding the case on its merits.

The case related to funding of Merino wool marketing, whereas the Judge's business interest was in a horse stud. It was accepted for the appellants that there was no connection between the Judge and the subject matter of the litigation. Furthermore, it was not suggested that he was actually motivated by any bias. The question was solely one of appearances. The Judge had no shareholding or directorship in the stud's operating company. His involvement with Mr Galbraith was restricted to a jointly owned landholding company which owned part of the land of the stud and itself bred one or two horses a year.

There were also three small broodmare partnerships. The result of the case in the Court of Appeal could have had no financial impact on Mr Galbraith or on the affairs of the stud. The Court has concluded that an objective lay observer, once acquainted with the facts concerning the business relationship, would not have found any logical reason, particularly in the absence of financial dependency between the Judge and Mr Galbraith, for the Judge to have unconsciously favoured the side represented by Mr Galbraith because of some fear of disadvantage to the Judge if the Wool Board were to be unsuccessful in the case.

Supreme Court

Must ReadView All

Textiles | On 6th Dec 2016

Garments, yarn export entitlement quota extended for 1 yr

Indian government has extended the export entitlement quota for...

Textiles | On 6th Dec 2016

Cash inflow will revive sales: Textile industry

The textile industry representatives are hopeful of revival of...

Courtesy: SIMA

Textiles | On 6th Dec 2016

Amma gave special attention for textile growth in TN: SIMA

Former Tamil Nadu chief minister J Jayalalithaa paid special...

Interviews View All

Divyesh Mashruwala
Akshar Industries

Surat dominates foiling, embossing and pleating

Nuno Venda
ROQ

‘There has been an increase in demand for water based inks, rather than...

Priyanka
Studio Priyanka Rajiv

‘To reinvent the age-old tradition of embroidery to suit demographics and...

Eric Scholler
Groz-Beckert

The Indian market has huge potential in technical textiles, and by far,...

Giorgio Mantovani
Corman S.p.A

Giorgio Mantovani, MD of Corman, with a presence in both Milano and New...

Steve Cole
Xerium Technologies

Steve Cole of Xerium Technologies discusses the industry. Xerium is the...

Robert Brunner
Devereux

Golfwear and menswear brand Devereux is set for greener pastures. Robert...

Silvia Venturini Fendi
Fendi s.r.l

"Yes, my confidence and positive attitude are my strengths and should be...

Pranav Mishra
Huemn

Designers Pranav Mishra and Shyma Shetty’s Huemn is known for its...

Press Release

Press Release

Letter to Editor

Letter to Editor

RSS Feed

RSS Feed

Submit your press release on


editorial@fibre2fashion.com

Letter To Editor






(Max. 8000 char.)

Search Companies





SEARCH
December 2016

December 2016

Subscribe today and get the latest update on Textiles, Fashion, Apparel and so on.

SUBSCRIBE


Browse Our Archives

GO


Advanced Search