Home / Knowledge / News / Textiles / Saxmere appeals against judgement in favour of Wool Board
Saxmere appeals against judgement in favour of Wool Board
25
Jul '09
Saxmere Co Ltd and associated appellants have appealed to the Supreme Court seeking the setting aside of a judgment of the Court of Appeal in favour of the Wool Board Disestablishment Co Ltd, adverse to the appellants, on the ground that the Hon Justice Wilson, a member of the Court of the Appeal Bench in that case, may have been unconsciously biased by reason of friendship and a business connection with one of the Wool Board's counsel in the case, Mr Galbraith QC.

The Supreme Court has unanimously dismissed the appeal holding that, in accordance with the well-established test, a fair-minded lay observer would not reasonably apprehend that the Judge did not bring an impartial mind to the resolution of the question before the Court of Appeal. The appellants have not articulated a logical connection between the Judge's friendship and business association with counsel and the possibility of some deviation by the Judge from the course of deciding the case on its merits.

The case related to funding of Merino wool marketing, whereas the Judge's business interest was in a horse stud. It was accepted for the appellants that there was no connection between the Judge and the subject matter of the litigation. Furthermore, it was not suggested that he was actually motivated by any bias. The question was solely one of appearances. The Judge had no shareholding or directorship in the stud's operating company. His involvement with Mr Galbraith was restricted to a jointly owned landholding company which owned part of the land of the stud and itself bred one or two horses a year.

There were also three small broodmare partnerships. The result of the case in the Court of Appeal could have had no financial impact on Mr Galbraith or on the affairs of the stud. The Court has concluded that an objective lay observer, once acquainted with the facts concerning the business relationship, would not have found any logical reason, particularly in the absence of financial dependency between the Judge and Mr Galbraith, for the Judge to have unconsciously favoured the side represented by Mr Galbraith because of some fear of disadvantage to the Judge if the Wool Board were to be unsuccessful in the case.

Supreme Court


Must ReadView All

Market share of Indian textile items expand in 13 nations

Textiles | On 11th Dec 2017

Market share of Indian textile items expand in 13 nations

Thirteen countries — Germany, France, Italy, the United States,...

Bangladesh garment exports rise 7.46% in July-Nov '17

Apparel/Garments | On 11th Dec 2017

Bangladesh garment exports rise 7.46% in July-Nov '17

Readymade garment exports from Bangladesh increased 7.46 per cent in...

Cotton price increase is not sustainable: ITF

Textiles | On 11th Dec 2017

Cotton price increase is not sustainable: ITF

The increase in cotton price seen last week is only a short-term...

Interviews View All

Kaizad Hansotia
GetNatty

Competition is the best thing that can happen to a startup

Smita Murarka
Amanté

‘There is huge demand in the Indian lingerie market for non-wired styles.’

Marazban F Velati
Sutlej Textiles & Industries limited

No training can be effective till the candidate believes in it.

Harmeet Singh

New Delhi-based Jogindra Industries Private Limited provides an assortment ...

Erik Sy

Manila-based CustomThread is a start-up offering premium custom apparel...

Suresh P Bagrecha

Komal Texfab, founded in 1981, is into manufacturing of knitted fabrics,...

Urs Stalder
Sanitized AG

Urs Stalder, CEO, Sanitized AG, talks about the increasing use of hygiene...

Giorgio Mantovani
Corman S.p.A

Giorgio Mantovani, MD of Corman, with a presence in both Milano and New...

Ashok Desai
Bombay Textile Research Association

Bombay Textile Research Association (BTRA) is a leading name in textile...

Anisha Chaudhari
Threads & Shirts

Threads & Shirts is a freshly-tailored concept providing men/women a...

Silvia Venturini Fendi
Fendi s.r.l

"Yes, my confidence and positive attitude are my strengths and should be...

Sidharth Sinha
Sidharth Sinha

<b>Sidharth Sinha</b> has contributed to the successful rebirth and...

Press Release

Press Release

Letter to Editor

Letter to Editor

RSS Feed

RSS Feed

Submit your press release on


editorial@fibre2fashion.com

Letter To Editor






(Max. 8000 char.)

Search Companies





SEARCH

December 2017

Subscribe today and get the latest update on Textiles, Fashion, Apparel and so on.

news category


Related Categories:

Planning to Take the Leap towards
Sustainability?

Do you see sustainability as a route to business growth?

Yes No

Do you think the sustainability space has the needed tools and resources available for a business to lead change?

Yes No

Active Poll

Do you see sustainability as a route to business growth?

Yes
69.2%
No
12.1%
Skip
18.7%

Total Votes: 91

Do you think adopting a sustainable approach will be a profitable move for your business?

Yes No

Active Poll

Do you think the sustainability space has the needed tools and resources available for a business to lead change?

Yes
61.5%
No
30.8%
Skip
7.7%

Total Votes: 91

Do you want the world to know about your sustainability journey and your business’ environmental footprint?

Yes No

Active Poll

Do you think adopting a sustainable approach will be a profitable move for your business?

Yes
86.8%
No
9.9%
Skip
3.3%

Total Votes: 91

Thanks for your valuable feedback. Claim your free latest sustainability e-book.

Active Poll

Do you want the world to know about your sustainability journey and your business’ environmental footprint?

Yes
81.3%
No
8.8%
Skip
9.9%

Total Votes: 91


E-News Insight
Subscribe Today and Get the
Latest News Update in Your Mail Box.
Advanced Search