Home / Knowledge / News / Apparel/Garments / Is the PE backed Indian apparel retail story turning sour?

Is the PE backed Indian apparel retail story turning sour?

17
Sep '12
Mr Siddharth Bafna
Is the PE backed, Indian apparel retail industry growth story falling apart or turning sour? Considering the increasing number of garment retailers who are suffering from growing debt pressures, more so those funded by Private Equity (PE) investors, it could be true to a certain extent.

These include the poster boys of Indian retail, particularly kidswear retailers like Lilliput and Gini & Jony. Lilliput is saddled with a huge debt and had fallen-out with PE investors Bain Capital and TPG. Gini & Jony also saw Reliance Capital exiting from the company. Other PE invested apparel retailers like Koutons and Spykar Jeans too are in trouble.

On the back of the unprecedented growth rates posted by the Indian economy in the first decade of the current century, clothing retailers went on an overdrive and opened new stores with funds borrowed from PE investors, without considering profitability and sales target ratios of each store.

The moot question that arises is – Were these PE investors not closely monitoring their investments in these retailers or are they themselves responsible for goading the retailers to expand indiscriminately. Mails sent to Indian offices of PE investors - Bain Capital and TPG remained unanswered.

According to a knowledgeable source, the apparel retailers put across sales figures of their high revenues generating stores in metro cities like Delhi or Mumbai and used them in calculating the revenues by multiplying these figures with, if they were to set up X number of stores. PE investors got sucked in by these figures and invested hugely in these retailers.

According to the same source, the Indian retail sector looked very promising in middle of last decade. However, these investors were not knowledgeable about the Indian retail industry nor did they have the experience of investing in retail in India. What they did not foresee was that a market like India has its very own set of challenges and did not realize the risks.

The retail markets in US and Europe are very different from those in India, the source reveals. A consumer over there does not think of throwing a shirt or footwear in the dustbin bought three months back, while an Indian consumer may wear it for 3 years or more. In short, the Indian market does not have the capacity to absorb these many numbers of brands. This is the most fundamental theory, the PE investors overlooked.

This is what led to the situation, in which well-known Indian apparel retailers are saddled with huge debts with banks and also the PE investors. Bellwether clothing retailers like Shopper’s Stop and Westside too could have expanded rapidly, considering the resources at their disposal. However they chose the profitability route rather than just hiking revenues, the source adds.

“When a PE investor invests in a company they have a five-year horizon. In order that their investment turns out to be profitable, they endeavour to increase the sales and profitability of the retailer and suggest rapid roll-outs of new stores”, explains Mr Siddharth Bafna, Partner at Lodha & Co.


Must ReadView All

Pic: Shutterstock

Textiles | On 18th Feb 2020

Turkey, Pak want to raise bilateral trade volume to $5 bn

Turkey and Pakistan want to raise bilateral commercial and economic...

Pic: Shutterstock

Apparel/Garments | On 18th Feb 2020

Bangladesh RMG exporters expect order shift from Cambodia

Bangladesh's readymade garment (RMG) exporters feel the suspension of ...

Pic: Shutterstock

Textiles | On 18th Feb 2020

IMF says Indian economic environment weaker than projected

There is an urgent need for more ambitious structural and financial...

Interviews View All

Top executives, Textile industry

Top executives
Textile industry

Denimsandjeans India 2018

Manuj Terapanthi, Texaura

Manuj Terapanthi
Texaura

Transparent supply chain and fair trade will boost sustainable market

Rashi Menda, Zapyle

Rashi Menda
Zapyle

Every fifth sale we make on Zapyle is a repeat purchase

Suresh P Bagrecha,

Suresh P Bagrecha

Komal Texfab, founded in 1981, is into manufacturing of knitted fabrics,...

Luciano Sardini,

Luciano Sardini

A consolidated reality in Italy and internationally, IMA Spa is well-known ...

Erwin Devloo,

Erwin Devloo

Picanol develops, produces and markets high-tech weaving machines, based...

Karl Zelik, Vanderbilt University

Karl Zelik
Vanderbilt University

A team of engineers at the Vanderbilt University has designed a smart...

Mr Ambrose Chan, DSG International (Thailand) PLC

Mr Ambrose Chan
DSG International (Thailand) PLC

Sven Ghyselinck, Devan Chemical

Sven Ghyselinck
Devan Chemical

Headquartered in Belgium and with offices in the United Kingdom, Portugal...

Sneha Arora, Label Sneha Arora

Sneha Arora
Label Sneha Arora

Sneha Arora, an alumnus of National Institute of Fashion Technology,...

Adriano Goldschmied, AG Jeans

Adriano Goldschmied
AG Jeans

The hype around 'designer jeans' was created by him. And the new wave of...

Amiben Shroff, Shrujan

Amiben Shroff
Shrujan

From its modest beginning in the late 1960s, Shrujan has grown into a...

Press Release

Press Release

Letter to Editor

Letter to Editor

RSS Feed

RSS Feed

Submit your press release on


editorial@fibre2fashion.com

Letter To Editor






(Max. 8000 char.)

Search Companies





SEARCH

Leave your Comments


February 2020

Subscribe today and get the latest update on Textiles, Fashion, Apparel and so on.


Advanced Search